Drone intensity in 3.6 JKU w/o resonator
#1
JK Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Was:Palmdale, CA Now: Cedar City UT
Posts: 286
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Drone intensity in 3.6 W/O resonator
A search of the threads did not yield anyone that had deleted their resonator describe how bad or at what speed(RPM) they experienced a drone sound as a result of removing their resonator. Every account I read where they deleted their resonator they had also changed their muffler. A resonator is different from a muffler in that a muffler basically reduces the sound at all frequencies whereas a resonator acts more like a notch filter and targets specific areas of the sound spectrum.thus reducing, or eliminating, a drone that would be heard at a specific speed or RPM.
I have relocated my canister filter in favor of installing an auxiliary fuel tank. If I remove the resonator and relocate the exhaust pipe slightly closer to the frame I could increase my tank size by around 3.75 gallons or so..
My question is, does anyone know the specifics of what I could expect if I were to remove the resonator? I've thought about replacing the stock resonator with a slimmer (perhaps a glass pack) resonator but a "resonator is a resonator", so to speak, and does not describe what the sound filtering characteristics would be for a particular resonator... So do I simply just delete or should I replace with a slimmer profile resonator, and if I were to install a different resonator which one or how to choose?
There is a lot of experience on this forum. I'm hoping someone can offer feedback on this subject.
KG6SLC aka Eugene
I have relocated my canister filter in favor of installing an auxiliary fuel tank. If I remove the resonator and relocate the exhaust pipe slightly closer to the frame I could increase my tank size by around 3.75 gallons or so..
My question is, does anyone know the specifics of what I could expect if I were to remove the resonator? I've thought about replacing the stock resonator with a slimmer (perhaps a glass pack) resonator but a "resonator is a resonator", so to speak, and does not describe what the sound filtering characteristics would be for a particular resonator... So do I simply just delete or should I replace with a slimmer profile resonator, and if I were to install a different resonator which one or how to choose?
There is a lot of experience on this forum. I'm hoping someone can offer feedback on this subject.
KG6SLC aka Eugene
Last edited by KG6SLC; 02-13-2019 at 09:43 PM. Reason: spelling
#2
Super Moderator
Magnaflow chimed in a while back and they had various solutions and descriptions of what/ where the resonator killed. Wish I could find the post but maybe they'll chime in again.
#3
Super Moderator
Join Date: Jun 2011
Location: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Posts: 11,035
Likes: 0
Received 80 Likes
on
72 Posts
You are going to have considerable drone if you remove the resonator. I am running the Magnaflow Offroad Pro exhaust, which is very nice, but it is loud and drones at highway speeds. It basically is just a muffler that dumps before the axle with no resonator. From the outside it sounds great but it is somewhat loud inside the cab. It is annoying to drive at highway speeds for prolonged times, so just be aware of that before going without one. I just crank up the stereo to drown it out lol.
#5
JK Freak
You are going to have considerable drone if you remove the resonator. I am running the Magnaflow Offroad Pro exhaust, which is very nice, but it is loud and drones at highway speeds. It basically is just a muffler that dumps before the axle with no resonator. From the outside it sounds great but it is somewhat loud inside the cab. It is annoying to drive at highway speeds for prolonged times, so just be aware of that before going without one. I just crank up the stereo to drown it out lol.
For a short while, I ran just the resonator with no muffler. It was incredibly obnoxious and embarrassing...until I got up to higher gears/highway speed. Then the resonator cut 90% of the drone out.
Ended up missing the muffler, so I replaced the bulky stock one with a small Magnaflow and tucked it up as high as I could. Very quiet now, but not as quiet as stock. Has a low grumble at lower speeds/start up now.
If the stock resonator is too big for your needs, find a smaller one and squeeze it inline somewhere.
You'd be better served replacing the Magnaflow axle back (which model?) with a smaller or more aggressive muffler. Resonator is there to deal with drone. Muffler is there to reduce overall noise. Removing the resonator will give you more grunt, but not what you're looking for.
Last edited by BoraBora; 02-18-2019 at 04:50 AM.
#6
I run 2 of our mufflers "inline".
Closest to the engine our Ultra Flo Welded stainless steel
Near the EVAP, our Race Bullet.
Drone is minimal but I do hear it when going through mountain passes.
Closest to the engine our Ultra Flo Welded stainless steel
Near the EVAP, our Race Bullet.
Drone is minimal but I do hear it when going through mountain passes.
#7
JK Enthusiast
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2011
Location: Was:Palmdale, CA Now: Cedar City UT
Posts: 286
Likes: 0
Received 2 Likes
on
2 Posts
Thanks to all for your input.
KG6SLC aka Eugene