I've been looking at a few tub mounted tire carriers. I'm going no larger than 35, will probably be on 33's for a while. I've narrowed the choices down to an Evo Pro and the Ace Engineering tub mounted tire carriers... I've read a bunch of stuff on both, but I haven't been able to really find any threads directly comparing the two. I'm interested in responses from people who actually have one of these tub mounted carriers. I know I probably won't get lucky enough to get someone who's had both, so I'll take what I can get.

Between these two, which one is better? i.e. rattles, production issues (like rubbing, having to modify product parts, etc.), ease (or lack of) installation, adjustability, durability over time...

I like some features of the Ace, like being able to mount 2 rotopax... But the Evo looks more sturdy than the Ace. Not saying the Ace isn't up to the task- just saying the Evo looks stronger... Neither are cheap, which is why I'm having a hard time deciding between the two... Anyhoo, experiences please!!