Another radiator fan question
#1
JK Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Scottsdale, AZ
Posts: 53
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Another radiator fan question
My apologies for another post, I have searched the forum, and everything comes "kinda" close, but not really...
2014 Sport, 30k miles (and of course out of warranty): runs "normal" (right between C and H), but at idle once at full temp (drive through, stoplight) darts up to just under the 3/4 hash. Then it appears the high speed fan turns on.
As I understand, there are 2 speeds/controls on the fan - low and high. Cranked it up, popped the hood. The fan blades try to turn, but nothing. I would describe it as a "jiggle". Turned the A/C on, still nothing (so now I'm wondering if my motor completely crapped out). This slight movement of the fan tells me there is something wrong with the motor.
Fuses good, swapped a relay, still nothing (so unless multiple relays are bad, I would assume the relay is good).
At this point, I am thinking it is the motor - but it has never got mud/water in the engine bay (not much of that in Phoenix).
How do I apply volts directly to the fan to see if that is it?
Should I just replace the fan motor at this point?
Thanks in advance - cheers
J^2
2014 Sport, 30k miles (and of course out of warranty): runs "normal" (right between C and H), but at idle once at full temp (drive through, stoplight) darts up to just under the 3/4 hash. Then it appears the high speed fan turns on.
As I understand, there are 2 speeds/controls on the fan - low and high. Cranked it up, popped the hood. The fan blades try to turn, but nothing. I would describe it as a "jiggle". Turned the A/C on, still nothing (so now I'm wondering if my motor completely crapped out). This slight movement of the fan tells me there is something wrong with the motor.
Fuses good, swapped a relay, still nothing (so unless multiple relays are bad, I would assume the relay is good).
At this point, I am thinking it is the motor - but it has never got mud/water in the engine bay (not much of that in Phoenix).
How do I apply volts directly to the fan to see if that is it?
Should I just replace the fan motor at this point?
Thanks in advance - cheers
J^2
#2
JK Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Scottsdale, AZ
Posts: 53
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Update...
Unplugged it and fed it some juice right off the battery, no luck.
At this point I have to believe the motor is shot, and the only way to replace is an entire fan assembly for $450....
Any recc's on an aftermarket fan? If I am going to spend $450, I might as well upgrade.....
At this point I have to believe the motor is shot, and the only way to replace is an entire fan assembly for $450....
Any recc's on an aftermarket fan? If I am going to spend $450, I might as well upgrade.....
#3
Super Moderator
So a couple bits of information for ya.
First, your fan isn't a 2-speed, it's variable. Jeep switched from a 2-speed to a variable speed in 2012.
Second, the OEM fan will outperform any aftermarket fan you can purchase. To the point that the folks that do V8 conversions use your model of fan. For example, MoTech uses the variable speed fan with their V8 conversions (they do upgrade the radiator though).
I say get the OEM.
First, your fan isn't a 2-speed, it's variable. Jeep switched from a 2-speed to a variable speed in 2012.
Second, the OEM fan will outperform any aftermarket fan you can purchase. To the point that the folks that do V8 conversions use your model of fan. For example, MoTech uses the variable speed fan with their V8 conversions (they do upgrade the radiator though).
I say get the OEM.
#4
JK Newbie
Thread Starter
Join Date: Mar 2009
Location: Scottsdale, AZ
Posts: 53
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Thanks jedg.
Dumb question - but feeding it directly off of the battery should work as a test, correct?
Knowing it is variable, I wonder why the low end stopped working on me?
guess I will purchase the OEM...thanks for the feedback
Dumb question - but feeding it directly off of the battery should work as a test, correct?
Knowing it is variable, I wonder why the low end stopped working on me?
guess I will purchase the OEM...thanks for the feedback
#5
Super Moderator
As for why it's not working at a lower voltage, perhaps the motor has some resistance in it now that it can't overcome at a lower voltage but does at a higher voltage. That's only a guess though.
At $450 for the replacement, I'd sure try to do some testing of the motor itself before making the purchase.