Notices
Stock JK Tech Bulletin board forum regarding issues with OE (original equipment) components of the Jeep JK Wrangler (Rubicon, Sahara, Unlimited and X) such as factory suspension parts, engine, transmission, body parts, interior fixtures and the on-board computer.

Mechanical Fan vs. Electric Fan

Thread Tools
 
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 10:18 AM
  #1  
Cowboy68's Avatar
Thread Starter
JK Newbie
Vet Army

 
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 19
Likes: 1
From: Smackover, AR
Default Mechanical Fan vs. Electric Fan

I am considering getting rid of my electric fan and going with a mechanical one. I would like to hear opinions/pros & cons for both fans.

I have never really liked electric fans, because they rely on temperature to come on as opposed to the mechanical fan always turning.
Reply
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 11:43 AM
  #2  
Ryan0260's Avatar
Super Moderator
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 11,054
Likes: 85
From: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Default

Mechanical fans rob hp. I have seen some people wire electric fans with a toggle switch and manually control them. That may be an option for you but you obviously would need to make sure it is turned on, and that just adds one more thing to worry about.

You could also keep the electric setup and just add an additional fan that is manually operated when you need it.
Reply
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 12:47 PM
  #3  
ronjenx's Avatar
JK Jedi Master
15 Year Member
 
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 12,904
Likes: 185
From: Maine
Default

Here is a link to a mechanical fan installation on a 3.8L JK. OEM Mechanical Fan Retrofit
Reply
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 02:58 PM
  #4  
Cowboy68's Avatar
Thread Starter
JK Newbie
Vet Army

 
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 19
Likes: 1
From: Smackover, AR
Default

Originally Posted by Ryan0260
Mechanical fans rob hp. I have seen some people wire electric fans with a toggle switch and manually control them. That may be an option for you but you obviously would need to make sure it is turned on, and that just adds one more thing to worry about.

You could also keep the electric setup and just add an additional fan that is manually operated when you need it.
How would a mechanical fan rob hp?
Reply
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 03:03 PM
  #5  
Cowboy68's Avatar
Thread Starter
JK Newbie
Vet Army

 
Joined: Aug 2020
Posts: 19
Likes: 1
From: Smackover, AR
Default

Originally Posted by ronjenx
Here is a link to a mechanical fan installation on a 3.8L JK. OEM Mechanical Fan Retrofit
I read that right after I posted my question. Very good write up and it gave me some ideas.
Reply
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 03:17 PM
  #6  
Ryan0260's Avatar
Super Moderator
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 11,054
Likes: 85
From: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Default

Originally Posted by Cowboy68
How would a mechanical fan rob hp?
Anything belt driven by the motor creates resistance and takes power to turn. This is why many drag racers use electric fans. Although it is likely only a few hp.
Reply
Old Aug 3, 2021 | 03:27 PM
  #7  
ronjenx's Avatar
JK Jedi Master
15 Year Member
 
Joined: Feb 2008
Posts: 12,904
Likes: 185
From: Maine
Default

Originally Posted by Ryan0260
Although it is likely only a few hp.
...at the top of the graph. Normal driving, it's not noticeable; in my experience, anyway.
Reply

Trending Topics

Old Aug 4, 2021 | 03:32 AM
  #8  
Ryan0260's Avatar
Super Moderator
10 Year Member
 
Joined: Jun 2011
Posts: 11,054
Likes: 85
From: Hendersonville, Tennessee
Default

Originally Posted by ronjenx
...at the top of the graph. Normal driving, it's not noticeable; in my experience, anyway.
I totally agree. He asked pros and cons and that is about all I can think of besides taking up more room under the hood. I think I have read it is likely 3-5 hp. But definitely nice to have the constant airflow a mechanical fan especially off road.
Reply
Old Aug 4, 2021 | 05:50 AM
  #9  
Sixty4x4's Avatar
Super Moderator
5 Year Member
Liked
Loved
Community Favorite
 
Joined: Dec 2018
Posts: 2,726
Likes: 506
From: Calgary, AB, Canada
Default

If you setup an aftermarket fan controller and run a PWM fan it will run based on temperature rise not at one setpoint to come on. I wheel in 95F temps going slow and I have the Chev Camaro SS PWM fan. First time after the Chev conversion out wheeling I stopped and opened the hood on a hot day and the fan was spinning about 10% and just moving the air. Then on the downhills and cooler days it hardly runs at all. Then climbing low speed and crawling it gets to a pretty high rate as I can hear it. So best of both worlds here. And the V8 uses to stock 3.8 rad as well. Hope this helps in your decision. If you decide on something like this you can buy an inline tee that taps into the top hose and gives you a temperature port to sense from. See attached


Last edited by Sixty4x4; Aug 4, 2021 at 06:01 AM.
Reply




All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:52 PM.