I have a 2000 Wrangler, mint with just under 18,000 miles that I picked up this summer. Had the spice hardtop in the garage during a party and it got trashed. Cracked beyond repair. Despite taking matters into my own hands and finding the culprits (apparently, a bunch of girls were sitting on the top when it happened), what is the best insurance route to go? I have read on here that some people have had their tops replaced no problem. What did they claim? Thanks.

PS

This thread is not to post any irrelevant responses regarding what should/could/would have been done "if." Lesson learned. Thanks.