Persoanlly, i think the hard top should match the fenders. besides that i have preference. i would get both i just don't like the mismatched parts

 

I started this thread to see what a whtie 4 door would look like with painted ahrd top and black fenders. I bought a used HT and was either going to paint it factory balck or white to match. End result was factory black. I just could not do it, call me a traditionalist. All these Jeeps look great, but man that is a ton of white.

 

Yep I get that, and that's great you went with black. I have a soft top for 6 months out of the year so I guess I get the best of both worlds. The white is cool up where I live because it snows so damn much it almost blends in except for the windows and wheels. it's preference for sure.

 

jku 11