Star or no star?
I like the star as well, but my personal preference would be to drop it a bit closer to the Wrangler sticker. This partially coincides with Toad's idea that the circular motif with the trail rated badge is a bit strong. With it lower, it would help balance out the visual association - just my opinion.
As far as the star not being respectful of the original Wil - a symbol can always be interpreted in many ways, what matters is how you view it yourself.
As far as the star not being respectful of the original Wil - a symbol can always be interpreted in many ways, what matters is how you view it yourself.




