Buying slightly used JK, gear ratio matter much?
 

I know the differences have been talked about extensively.
I am buying a non-rubicon. Should i stress very much over the gear ratio? I'd prefer the 3.73, but they are very hard to find. Is it worth losing sleep over if i have to settle for 3.21?
It will be a daily driver with light off road use occasionally. I might put larger tires on.
I'd prefer a 6 speed over Automatic, but again, hard to find. I'd settle with a post 2012 automatic.
Thanks

Well. I'll chime in with it is a very big investment and that you shouldn't settle for anything less than you want. If you want 3.73 get them. Of course gears can be upgraded later and you may need to if you go up in tire size.

The big thing you mentioned was manual vs auto. If you want the manual don't settle for the auto cause you really can't change that down the road.

Bottom line is be patient and don't settle. Get what you want and you will be happier driving it.

Depending on size of tires you're thinking.....3.73 are likely to not really be enough anyhow. I wouldn't worry about gearing at all at purchase, and just budget ~$1500 to regear to what you'd REALLY need at the appropriate time. If you factor in the cost of a regear in to a purchase price, it's really not that big of a deal......and if it's a vehicle you'll have for a long time, it is well worth it. I would focus more on mileage, engine, body, and overall condition.

I would say that 3.21 is ok if you don't go with bigger tires. The first mile you drive after getting bigger tires with 3.21 you will ask yourself wtf did I just do? So, either hold out for 3.73 or budget the regear. However, based on what I've read on here, I think regearing from 3.21 to something higher will cost you more than $1500. I'm thinking more like $2000.

You can get away with 3.21 and a manual as long as you don't go too big on the tires. But if you go steel wheels and bumpers and add a bunch of weight you may have to regear later. Not so much with an auto.