...having my fenders and hardtop painted the same color as my Jeep. I'm starting to dig that look. Question: can I have the stock fender professionally painted or will I have to buy news ones?

 

Your probably going to be better off buying new ones. It will be extremly difficult to get the rough finish off of both the hardtop and fenders
I wanted to colormatch my fenders and top a little while ago and i called a ton of shops and almost nobody would even attempt it

 

I think the top will be fine. Maybe get new fenders or find some Sahara ones in your jeep's color