Sounds like a good plan. Let us know what you think after you test drive it and how it feels. I will say strictly for comparison sake thou that on my last 2008 JKU that pulling a small trailer with two 350 pound sport bikes and some extra tires in an open type drive on trailer that I felt it pretty big on the highway or any kind of hill. Even with double axles and brakes it still would sway at times due to the tires on the Jeep. The same trailer pulled with my buddies f150 and you didnt even remember you were pulling something. Either way I hope you find something that works for ya.

Quick edit... If I had the clams and wanted a pimp toyhauler for my jeep this is probably what I would be dragging around.

http://www.rvingplanet.com/brands/ai...avel-trailers/

KZ Sportman 16FKTH
 

KZ sportman has a small toy hauler that I have been looking at, its GVWR is 3500 lbs and I think it will pull well behind my 2012 JKU.