I have rugged ridge and it works good. No tools on and off. Rolls up nice and I tie it down to the rear cross bar of cage and its always there when I need it and our of the way. Install by myself about 10-15 minutes max. Has pockets on the inside with zipper. Easy fit 10 CDs and wallet and such.

 

The freedom panels without the hard top make a great bikini top.

 

I run the shade year round. Don't notice the gap anymore and no issues with sag/flapping.

 

We run the Rugged Ridge Eclipse top. Does the job well and is installed / removed in minutes.