Just checking with you guys to make sure this combo will be okay. Jeep has a 2.5" lift. I still can't decide on which tire though. Is it worth the 75 over the 70 for $40 each? Anyone have a pic with this setup?

 

I think you will be happier with the 35x12.5 in the long run I got mine installed for 300 per tire
Also a 9" wheel is wide for either of the metric sizes you mentioned

 

That's a 285-70-17 on a 9" wide wheel with no lift. If I were you I would get the 75s

 

Hmm.. those are 330 on Amazon.. maybe I'll hit up discount tire. I was going to get it all installed there anyway.

Would the 35 do okay on that wheel?

 

Yes a 9" wheel would be perfect for the 35

 

LT285/70R17 E121/118Q 205-930 18.9 33.15 11.81 7.5-(8.5)-9.0 3195/2910@80
LT285/75R17 E121/118Q 205-950 18.9 34.09 11.57 7.5-(8.0)-9.5 3195@80
LT295/70R17 E121/118P 205-710 19.4 33.54 11.97 7.5-(8.5)-10.0 3195@80
LT315/70R17 D121/118Q 205-940 20.0 34.61 13.27 8.0-(9.5)-11.0 3195/2910@50
35x12.50R17LT E121Q 205-730 21.0 34.84 13.19 8.5-(10.0)-11.0 3195@65


Specs from Nitto on suggested wheel sizes

 

Those tires are heavier than the average mud terrain tire? Do you have an aftermarket tire carrier.

 

I would go with the bigger size, and yes that wheel is fine for either tire

 

Okay, I'm about to order. Anything wrong with this combo?

Pro Comp Alloys 7031 Flat Black Wheel (16x8"/5x5")

Pro Comp Tire 56315 Xtreme AT 315/75R16

 

That will work... just a little narrower... it's really what you think. Me, I prefer the 12.50" wide tires but it's a preference thing. All other performance should be very similar.