Weathertech all the way...

 

Don't buy the AEV ones they are thin, flimsy and way overpriced. The rubber is also very porous, they seem to absorb the dirt. I just made the mistake

 

I'm running my wife's winter mats out of her 07 Mazda 3. She hasn't noticed yet and they fit fairly well.

 

So you do not like the AEV ones. I am looking between AEV, quadratec, and weathertec.

These are mainly to keep sand out of my carpets and clean from slush in 5 he winter.
here are my feelings from the reviews and photos.

AEV: I like the coverage especially in the back seat, they are a bit pricey. I like their design pattern.

Quadratec: great price, supposedly solid construction and fit well. I do not like the tread pattern or how the cargo mat has a rear lip.

Weathertec: most expensive, solid design and excellent fit. Not as much coverage in the rear seat as the other two.

Anyone have any input on the 3?

 

Love my Weathertech in the front row and cargo area. Didnt like the coverage for the second row, so I kept the OEM rubber liner for the back seat.

 

AEV matts rock!!!

 

I have had the Tuffy and the newer Quadratec "tread lighly" liners. The quadratec ones have held up nice. The tuffys lip was flimsy and creased so I sold them. Hope that helps.