So, I'm down to two different bumpers that I'm looking at and was wondering if anyone has a review or two on the following bumpers (my search-fu got nothing):

Expedition One Jeep JK basic DX™ Winch Bumper


or

Rancho Front Off-Road Bumper


They're about the same price, but what's the weight comparison and how do they hold up in the long run especially when they roll over assorted terrain?

Thanks guys!