So you are comparing the all terrains? They are both very similar, so I would go for whichever you can get the better deal on.

 

I've got the Nittos in 37" and I'm very happy with them.

 

I have the toyo mt In 285/75/17 and i love them. I have 75,k on them now.

 

I had the same debate, along with A/T vs. M/T. They're going to last 50k miles so make your choice wisely...

 

I had the Toyo's when I was on 35's, wen to Nitto with 37's. I think I will go back to Toyo's next time. I think they wore a little better.

 

I have Toyo open country at2 285/75-16's on my JKU and very happy. I have 12000 miles on them and they lokk like they well go another 50000 miles or so. Hardly any wear and they have worn very even, no signs of odd wear at all. Very quiet and excellent in snow, ice, rock, sand. I have not had them in any real deep mud so not sure how they will do in mud but everything else they have been awesome. They are incredibly smooth for an E rated tire. I hear lots of people say they are heavy but I weighed mine and not bad at 53 lbs.