I have a 2 door wrangler. Just ordered a 2 inch spacer lift, 16 x8 cragars with 5 inch back spacing. 33 Bf goodrich AT tires that are 11.5 inches wide. Will this set up look balanced, not to narrow, not to wide. The guys at my local jeep shop say it will.

 

It mostly depends on your preference. I like the combo you listed. It seems to stuff well. I cant remember the vendor, but one of them had a nice ramp shot with really goo d articlation. Some prefer to have the wheel fill out the well more, & feel like 2" leaves too much air between the well & tire. Width wise, I believe you'll have a wee bit of tire sticking out. I like a tiny bit out ut some states don't tolerat this at all.