Looking for opinions... nervous about rubbing. 80% on road, probably 20% off.

I'm thinking of going with 3 different tires:

BFG KM2
Goodyear Duratrac
Goodyear MTR with Kevlar

Going with 35x12.5x17 or with 315/70r17 and I'm not sure which is "safer" and which one will "look" better with a 2.5 inch lift on my 2012 JKU. I've already bought my pintlers but I just need to figure out the tire situation.

Any advice is appreciated.

 

Any of those tires in 35s would fit with no rubbing on the plinters. Maybe on airdam at full turn, but just lose it.

 

Will any of them not rub on the air dam?