So... I'm back. Bought another JK. I've had a "bad power steering" sound for about 4 months. Replaced the pump...still there. Replaced tensioner pulley...still there. Sound comes from the oil pan (I have a stethoscope). I finally caved, and took it to the stealership. I told them I tracked the sound to the oil pan. They replaced the tensioner pulley. FML. Sound is still there (duh). To add to that, they made me a whole new sound to figure out! Listen to the video with sound way up. I took it back. They said "All sounds normal"... insinuating that I'm crazy. I'm done with these clowns already.
VIDEO:
https://youtu.be/dCTIulyJehE