Which Tire?
I personally wouldn't go with either. For an agressive looking all terrain (looks more like a mud terrain than an all terrain) I'd go with a Duratrac. It's great in most conditions. Especially winter driving as they're snowflake rated. They look real good in person too. Better than they do in pictures.
I put about 20K miles on a set of BFG ATs on my '98 TJ, and thought they were pretty good until I put a set of Good Year Silent Armor ATs on my '08 JKU. The Silent Armors have two steel belts and one KEVLAR belt. They are (1) silent on road, (2) top rated on wet and icy roads and are (3) rated for "severe snow service." Not a problem in Arkansas. Off road they will hold their own on trails, moderate rocks and deep sand. They absolutely suck in deep mud. That all being said, if you spend more than 90% of your time on road, an aggressive tire is not what you need. BUT, if that's what you want, go to it.
I upgraded from the factory 255's to Goodyear Duratrac's 285's with good wheel spacers.
matthew




