While the JK was at the dealership for the Chirp I asked them to rotate the Tires only cuz it was free... and today I noticed that they rotated in the spare that had never seen the road, after 19000km. Is this OK? My steering felt a little flighty and I was wondering why now I think that is the answer... is this cool or are they dumbasses and is this safe?

 

They probably assumed you had already done so and didn't bother to look hard enough. In my opinion it's a good thing unless perhaps you don't plan on changing tire size or brand at the end of the life for your current set of tires.

 

actually come spring time, I will be putting my lift(OME) and changing out the tires for some 33's... was hoping to keep one new one.. oh well as long as its not dangerous..