The total quotes (shipped) for 5 x BFG Mud-Terrain T/A KM2s are:

Tire Crawler: $1,214.45

Tire Rack: $1,263.50

Discount Tire Direct: $1,265.00

WalMart: $1,279.25 (SC tax included)

I am thinking of just skipping the trouble of trying to contact Discount Tire Direct, and just ordering online from Tire Crawler.

I couldn't wait on a reply from Discount Tire Direct; bought from Tire Crawler.

Thanks for all the help guys!

Why didn't you just call them?
DT price matches and beats anyone's price, plus free shipping, and you don't pay tax when buying from out of state.

It looks like they don't sell any 37" tires.

I am deployed overseas, it is very hard to call an 800 number from my location. I want to contact a rep so I can get a JK-Forum discount on on the 5 LT255 80 17 BF Goodrich Mud-Terrain T/A KM2s that I want to buy for my just-delivered 2013 JKUR.

tread depot has some good deals too

Same experience here. Never replied to my emails. Bought cheaper from somewhere else. Hope you have better luck.

Had the same great experience with DTD. Steel 16 wheels were in my price range and he game me a set of mb72s for the same price as the steelies. I have them on 35 GYDTs and love em. It's the 3rd time I bought tires from them and all 3 times were great.

Matt from Discount Tire Direct did eventually shoot me an email; just 24 hours than I needed it.

I really can't hold anything against them, as I made the order on Christmas Eve. Tire Crawler still has no tracking number for me, and has the order listed as "processing."

I would like to state that the service I received with Discount Tire Direct was exemplary.
Unfortunately, the order was stolen from my porch, but DTD didn't wait for UPS to make a claim, they simply sent me a new set. They are taking the loss up with UPS.
In the end, it took a week and a half instead of 3 days, because of New Years and a weekend, but I still have my tires and I'm happy with them. I can't rec DTD enough.