New Tires!! Can't Decide!!
You can always buy online from a place like Tread Depot (they had the lowest prices when I bought mine...including shipping) and just get them mounted by a local shop. That is, assuming your local shop will mount and balance tires not purchased from them.
If you're thinking about the toyo's you should also consider Nitto trail grappler, almost the same but nittos are a littler lighter and a bit cheaper, I love mine, they have a little road noise but I like it.



