When I got my jeep I sold the soft top for 450.00. The top was on the vehicle and had been laid back maybe 2-3 times. Bought in October. I priced it at 500.00 on Craigslist and within 2 days it was gone for 450.00. He offered 400.00 and 450.00 is what we settled on. So a new top will go all day at the 500.00 dollar mark with all hardware. That's my 2 cents. Try to snag it for cheap, but like new or new is hard to come by for less than 500.00. I've been looking now 2 years later for a new one for what I sold mine for since march and have found nothing close. Everybody's proud of those new tops.

 

I paid 280 for mine with all the hardware as mine was hardtop only to start, its a used top but nothing wrong with it, I would agree a '12 top is gonna be more than 300 but might as well try