Okay...okay...I will spill the beans. Your tail light. Hide the spare in the tail light. Then, if worse came to worse all you need is a screwdriver, even the little ones on a swiss army knife key chain will work. This is what I did on my YJ & TJ...come to think of it I need to check to see if this JK uses a standard screw or if the tailights are held on by some torx?!?!?!

 

I just put my key in my pocket and my cash & cards in my wallet.

 

i know whyd you put money and a credit card in your storage thingy? sounds dumb. haha but the key part is a good idea.