Prevent hitting deer ?
it didn't cost me anything, it was free came with some papers in the mail i think, it had a little adhesive pad on the bottom so i figured it couldn't hurt anything, as far as it working i don't know, many mixed reviews on it and i drive about 40-60 on our roads so it should work, don't get me wrong i'm not dependant on the thing i always keep my eyes open and am aware
I think the thing with most of those warning whistles is speed. If you go slow they are not loud enough to do the job. I have used them for years and by the time I see the dear they are always running the other way. From experience if you go under 40 mph you may as well not have them.
I think the general concensus is that if you're goin under 40, you oughtta be able to stop fairly quickly.
I was told once by a Forest Ranger that deer cross a road and suddenly see 2 big eyes in the dark (headlights). They fear for their safety. The deer don't know what is in front of them so they retrace their steps and return across the road to the safety they know was behind them. I personally don't think the Deer Whistles do all that much (if anything) to alert the deer. They have a very acute sense of hearing and I believe they are more than capable of hearing the engine of a vehicle coming down the road from a long distance away. If you stand quietly on a dark night and listen, you can hear cars a long distance away. Deer can hear much better than humans so I don't think any vehicle will sneak up on them. We lived in Wisconsin years ago and I know first hand about the large deer population there. No one thought the Deer Whistles worked but they used them anyway "just in case". Meanwhile deer were hit every night. Do they work? IMHO, yes, for the factory that sells them and count your money. Hope this doesn't get anyone angry at me. If you think they are a good idea, then by all means use them "just in case".
Your forrest ranger was so full of crap his eyes were brown. Deer instinctively freeze when hit by light. That's why people get put IN JAIL for "shining" deer at night. Put the spotlight on um...they freeze and you shoot the SHIT outta them. It's illegal as all HELL. I've lived in deer country all my life. They will stand in the road until you RUN their stupid asses over if they are blinded by your headlights. That forrest ranger needs to go work at Burger King or somethin. The deer whistles are to make damn SURE they hear you comin LONG before you get there so they will NOT be in the road to get blinded by headlights. I'll put it to you like this: Geico Insurance company gives DISCOUNTS if you have them on your car. Trust me when I say if an insurance company gives you a discount for somethin, IT WORKS.
Last edited by RedneckJeep; Mar 3, 2008 at 10:21 PM.
To more or less confirm the speed theory the only times I actually had them still in the road are the times I was stuck behind someone going under 35 MPH.
There is no way they would put them on at the factory. That would be a lawsuit waiting to happen. If you would hit a dear with you car the first thing everyone would do is go after the car manufacturer. and as I said if you do not drive fast enough they are not effective.
Where the heck are the Mythbusters when we need them. I'll volunteer my Jeep if Kari is the one working on this question ...





