Got to recommend the Nitto Trail Grapplers. I run 35x12.50-18, great off road and on the highway. Very little road noise, too.

 

I run KUMHO MTs... they're comparable to Nitto & Toyo but run a little cheaper. They aren't too loud or too heavy for a 35" mud terrain.

 

I have these as well. Didn't have a chance to try them out in the snow as i got them in march and winter was pretty much over. they are however noisy and are difficult to balance. pretty good wear and grip but i wouldn't buy them again. would definately go toyo or nitto next time around

 

Nice Jeep!, those plasti-dip wheels look great with those tires.

 

Just went though the same dilemma... Finally pulled the trigger on Toyo M/T. The only complaint I have ever heard is that they are heavy (which is correct). TOTALLY impressed, you won't regret it. BTW, I talked to quite a few local shops (CO) who said the Toyos are far superior in the snow... Assuming it ever snows again. Happy shopping.